Battered women as court defense essay

Tweet Women in physically abusive relationships have been known to take extreme measures against their spouses or boyfriends such as by killing them or inflicting serious bodily harm if they felt their own safety or life was at risk.

Battered women as court defense essay

These are the things that they will only be enlightened with if told by the woman in court. They were not there when she was being threatened.

Legal Defense of BWS

The Battered Women Syndrome. The woman believes that the violence was or is her fault. The woman has an inability to place the responsibility for the violence elsewhere. The woman has an irrational belief that the abuser is omnipresent and omniscient.

This is because the symptoms come about after a dramatic, or traumatizing, event. Obviously the first time a woman is abused is a traumatizing experience.

Battered Women - Domestic Violence |

Francine Hughes, The Burning Bed Francine Hughes was trapped, in a seemingly never ending cycle with a man who appeared aloof to the rest of the world and surly to her. There is that single second of adrenaline and that last rodeo in which God becomes your best friend as you fight for life.

In a single sentence, Francine Hughes had enough. The date was March 9th, Mickey Hughes resembled a Barcelona bull. He began beating up Francine in one of their most violent collisions. He was pulling her hair and hitting her with his disgustingly familiar hands.

Battered women as court defense essay

He then proceeded to burn her secretarial course books. Mickey threatened to take a sledgehammer to her car to prevent her from going to school. He complained about the food she made, and took away her dignity by smearing garbage all in her hair and face.

When he went to bed, Francine contemplated. She then decided to take the chance, she knew she had no other choice. After 14 years of abuse, she was now going to turn the table around. Hughes went out and into the garage and got gasoline, then made her way up to the bedroom and poured it all over the bed with Mickey lying in it.

She took a match, and just like all of the affliction and despondency she dealt with, Mickey Hughes began to burn in flames. Although she told the court that he had threatened her life and that the murder was self defense, the jury decided that she was not guilty due to temporary insanity.

This case made her a national infamy and broadcasted BWS to the nation.

[Content note: hostility toward social justice, discussion of various prejudices] “Words! Words! Words! I’m so sick of words! I get words all day through. JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary sources. American Journal of Criminal Law; The Value of Civilian Handgun Possession as a Deterrent to Crime or a Defense Against Crime, by Don B. Kates.

The court was told that during their relationship, Angelique was regularly abused by Rust. A psychiatrist testified in her trial that she had been threatened by Rust and that she felt suffocated and incapable of escaping the relationship.

Gollom, 5 cases using the battered women defence, The case eventually went to the Supreme Court, where the subject focused on whether the evidence of the psychiatrist should have been before the court.

The top court agreed that the evidence was relevant, showing that the Battered Woman Syndrome is a genuine defense. A lot of people think this is the first BWS case in Canada. But the judge ruled the evidence irrelevant, and Napolitano was found guilty.

Even though the jury suggested mercy, the judge condemned her to hang.

Battered women as court defense essay

Napolitano became a notoriety at the time, with many supporting her sentence be changed. The federal cabinet did change her sentence to life, and she was allowed parole 11 years later. Like an answer to a math problem I have a solution. Now, a woman could potentially go into court, with the accusation of murder, and use the Battered Women Syndrome to get away with it.

She could potentially use it as the one thing the syndrome is accused of; an excuse. But what if a woman comes in and was actually in a life or death situation with the abuser?Losing the War.

Man is a bubble, and all the world is a stormJeremy Taylor, Holy Dying () My father owned a gorgeous porcelain tiger about half the size of a house cat. The battered woman defense is a defense that is used in court to defend assault/murder charges where the defendant is abused and commits a offence under duress or necessity.

The Value of Civilian Handgun Possession as a Deterrent to Crime or a Defense Against Crime

It is mainly used by women and also referred to as the battered woman syndrome/battered wife syndrome. Here are the sections you will find: Section 1: What I'll be discussing in this how-to essay; Section 2: Understand who or what you're hiding from.

Archives and past articles from the Philadelphia Inquirer, Philadelphia Daily News, and One of the theoretical frameworks present, which is explains the rationale for battered women killings as a supplement to a self-defense court appeal is the condition of battered woman syndrome (Ogle and Jacobs, p.

51). mothers rights, law and legal research, family politics, feminism, sociology, children, divorce, custody, parenting.

Losing the War - by Lee Sandlin